Ninety carats is the largest number in a sale, and it is not always the one that sets the price. At Christie’s Luxury Evening Sale in Shanghai on 13 November, the headline lot — a necklace built around a 90.80-carat light-brown diamond — sold below the low end of its own estimate, while the coloured stones and the signed ring in the same sale sold inside theirs. The sale, held to mark Christie’s 40th anniversary in Asia, made CNY 38.6 million in total.

The necklace is called the Starlight, and it was made by William Goldberg. Its centre stone is a pear brilliant-cut diamond of 90.80 carats, graded in the W-to-X colour range, VS2 clarity, and classed as type IIa. The stone hangs from a rectangular-cut yellow diamond, on a chain of pear-shaped pink diamonds and colourless diamonds of various cuts. It sold for CNY 8.3 million (about C$1.7 million), just under its pre-sale estimate of CNY 8.6 million to CNY 18 million.
The miss is small — CNY 300,000 below the low estimate — and it is worth reading exactly, rather than as a failure. The room did not reject the necklace; it priced it slightly below where the house had set the floor. What the stone carries is size and a light-brown colour graded far down the white-diamond scale, in the W-to-X range. What it does not carry is the saturated colour or the famous signature that drove the prices immediately below it in the same sale.
The lots that held their estimates
Those prices held. A Tiffany & Co. ring with a round brilliant-cut diamond of 11.69 carats, D colour, internally flawless and also type IIa, sold for CNY 5.5 million, inside its estimate of CNY 4.8 million to CNY 6.8 million. A ring centred on a heart-shaped Muzo emerald from Colombia of 6.84 carats, surrounded in part by Argyle pink diamonds, sold for CNY 4.3 million, inside its estimate of CNY 3.4 million to CNY 5 million. An oval royal-blue Burmese sapphire of 21.87 carats sold for CNY 4.1 million, and a fancy vivid yellow diamond of 14.58 carats, internally flawless, also sold for CNY 4.1 million — both inside the same estimate range, CNY 3.2 million to CNY 5 million. A Wallace Chan brooch in the shape of a rearing stallion sold for CNY 2.9 million, inside its estimate of CNY 2.6 million to CNY 4.3 million.
Colour first, carats after
Read as one sale, the pattern is plain. Every lot at the top of this sale whose price rested on saturated colour — a Muzo emerald, a royal-blue sapphire, a vivid yellow diamond — or on a signature and a top colour grade, in the Tiffany ring, met the house’s own valuation. The one lot whose claim was principally weight, in a light-brown stone, came in just beneath it. That is not a verdict on brown diamonds in general, and one evening in Shanghai cannot carry that weight. It is a record of how this room, on this night, ordered its priorities: colour and name first, carats after.
The figures also have a limit, and it should be stated. The prices of the individual lots and the sale total were reported by the trade press after the sale; Christie’s own results listing confirms the sale and its total. No buyer for the Starlight necklace was named in the reporting. What is established is the order of the evening: the biggest stone led the sale in price, as expected — and still finished below the line its own house had drawn for it, while colour, in four different stones, did not.
— Tom